Terra Cole Butchery: Hip, tasty deli fare at down-to-earth prices
At Terra Cole Butchery in West Seattle, expect all the trimmings of an artisanal deli, with none of the steep prices.
Seattle Times staff reporter
Terra Cole Butchery & Fine Foods
4541 California Ave. S.W., Seattle; 206 258-2475 www.terracolebutchery.com
Hours: 11 a.m.-7 p.m. Tuesday-Saturday and 11 a.m.-6 p.m. Sunday
Etc: major credit cards accepted; no obstacles to access; sells beer and wine
Seattle, it seems, is never happy with its sandwich scene. We went through a phase of “why don’t we have more sandwich shops like in Portland?” to “why are these new gourmet sandwich joints charging north of $10?”
Well, Terra Cole Butchery & Fine Foods opened along the main drag of West Seattle, hawking Reubens and other hot sandwiches for just $7.50.
The menu: It’s a menu of six sandwiches all served hot, though the deli will add other lighter, cold sandwiches once the weather warms up. It’s a short menu, with a few soups-of-the-day and a few sides, like potato salad. All meats are smoked and made in-house. The rest of the operation is devoted to selling charcuterie and raw meat.
What to write home about: The meaty “Dudewich” is a gluttonous sloppy joe soaked up in a dripping blue cheese fondue, the soft brioche bun a mere vessel to get said meat to mouth. It won’t all make it, but what you do manage on the first try will go down nicely with an IPA.
Even better is the Reuben, with stacks of red ale-braised corned beef, topped with some crunchy brussel-sprout-sauerkraut. The peppery and smoky pastrami, though a bit chewy and lean, is still one of the better pastramis on rye in Seattle. Your day-after Thanksgiving turkey sandwich can be had here year round — chunks of dark turkey meat, slathered with cranberry relish and stuffing, bound with mayo in a hoagie.
What to skip: The dry and salty “Pulled South Carolina BBQ Pork.”
The setting: A spacious, nondescript white-walled joint, Terra Cole feels old school, none of the subway tiles and other Brooklyn-butcher-shop-inspired décor that’s hip now. Plenty of tables and seats are available in front to accommodate a busy lunch rush.
Summing up: Five sandwiches, each $7.50, totaled $41.06 after tax, enough to feed five.
Tan Vinh: 206-515-5656 or firstname.lastname@example.org. On Twitter @tanvinhseattle