Was poisoning of biologist’s dog a warning from Calif. pot growers?
Wildlife disease expert Mourad Gabriel’s dog died from a “super-toxic” rat poison that had been killing the area’s wildlife, and the biologist believes it’s only a matter of time before the toxic compounds leap from the animal food chain to humans.
Los Angeles Times
BLUE LAKE, Calif. — Super Bowl Sunday was a quiet day for wildlife disease expert Mourad Gabriel. He and his wife, Greta Wengert, an ecologist, planned to watch the game, then peel off to do some work.
Their house, on the crest of a wooded knoll near the Northern California coastal town of Arcata, is open and sunlit. From the kitchen table where Gabriel often works, he can see the sloping backyard where the family’s two boisterous Labrador retrievers loved to play.
One of the dogs, Nyxo, was rescued from a local shelter. The dog frequently kept the 39-year-old biologist company during his fieldwork, which includes studying the decline of the Pacific fisher — a forest predator, related to the weasel, that is a candidate for inclusion on the federal endangered-species list later this year.
After the football game, the couple turned in. The next morning, Wengert found Nyxo on the floor writhing in pain. Hours later, he was dead.
Gabriel drove the body to the University of California, Davis, to help perform a necropsy in a lab where he often worked. Pathologists opened Nyxo’s chest and found it filled with blood — a clear indication that the dog had died from a particularly nasty “super-toxic” rat poison that Gabriel and colleagues had written about in 2012.
Their scientific paper had linked the toxin to the deaths of Pacific fishers. The creatures had eaten rodents poisoned by illegal marijuana growers across California, including those hidden in Humboldt County’s lushly forested mountains.
In a county whose economy is driven by the marijuana trade, the findings made Gabriel a target. Comments on websites warned that “snitches wind up in ditches.” An email inquiring about where he lived was traced by federal authorities to Mexico, suggesting that he had enemies among drug cartels.
Gabriel reported his dog’s death to Humboldt County Sheriff Mike Downey. In the 13 weeks since, his department’s investigation has yielded no leads. Despite a $20,000 reward, his deputies have gotten almost no cooperation from the public.
“We have an old-time saying in Humboldt County,” Downey said. “‘Our hills contain a lot of things we don’t know about.’”
Gabriel’s troubles have roots in a 2009 necropsy he performed on a Pacific fisher.
Beady-eyed and hatchet-headed, the animals are a relative of the weasel, with shortish brown fur with tufts of white. They are long and slender, the adults measuring up to 4 feet and weighing 5 to 13 pounds. Their hind legs can rotate nearly 180 degrees, allowing them to scamper down trees head first. They range from California to Washington state.
The necropsy was on an outwardly healthy young male, known as M05, whose carcass had been found high in the Sierra near Yosemite National Park. Gabriel and pathologists at the UC Davis’ California Animal Health and Food Safety Lab could see that it was not killed by a mountain lion or bobcat, responsible for most fisher deaths. And there was no sign of disease.
But when the team cut into the body, they found the chest and abdominal cavity brimming with blood. The fisher had lost nearly 80 percent of its blood.
The wildlife experts were mystified. Whatever led to this savage hemorrhagic response was like nothing they had ever seen.
Weeks later, lab results isolated the cause: a super-toxic rat poison banned for sale to the public.
Finding the poison in that first fisher set off alarm bells because the animals are in decline. The Pacific fisher population has dwindled to below 2,000 in two population clusters in the Sierra Nevada. How had the rodenticide found its way into a rare animal living in the middle of nowhere?
Feverishly working backward, Gabriel and the other pathologists retested tissue samples from every fisher they had collected since 2005. To their horror, nearly 80 percent tested positive for rodenticides. Some fishers had four or five types of poison in their systems.
Gabriel said pathologists did not find rat bait in the animals’ stomachs. Rather, they had been exposed to the poison by preying on rodents that had eaten the bait.
Further, the scientists noticed a pattern of high mortality in early spring, when marijuana seedlings sprout and growers spread bait to kill deer mice and other rodents. Under federal Environmental Protection Agency restrictions, the super-toxics can be sold only to professional exterminators and employees of farms, warehouses and other commercial operations. However, the banned rat bait is readily available to anyone online.
Aware that rodenticides bioaccumulate in tissue and are passed up the wildlife food chain, researchers wondered what other animals could be carrying the poisons. Gabriel tested other animals that came through the lab and promptly detected rat poisons in two spotted owls. He collected samples from five groups of insects found at a marijuana plantation. All had rodenticide in their systems.
A state game warden told Gabriel a mother bear and two cubs had been encountered, foaming at the mouth and convulsing, eating a cache of poison at an illegal grow site.
Gabriel’s work has caused wildlife biologists to rethink assumptions about the causes of species declines.
Wildlife repeatedly exposed to rodenticides would become quasi-hemophiliacs, subject to massive bleeding when suffering the slightest wound. Animals could bleed out after a single shallow bite, but researchers would attribute the death to a predator. Data about the cause of wildlife deaths may be skewed by the unknown toll of the poisons.
Gabriel believes it’s only a matter of time before the toxic compounds leap from the animal food chain to humans. In the fall he’s hoping to examine tissue from hunter-killed game animals, especially livers.
“Toxins are stored in the liver,” he said. “Hunters eat deer and bear livers.”
Marijuana cultivation, illegal and otherwise, is highly lucrative for underground growers and the legitimate businesses that cater to them in Humboldt County.
It also drives a high crime rate. As much as 80 percent of the region’s violent crime is associated with marijuana, said Downey, whose department as recently as 10 days ago arrested a grower for murder.
Authorities believe Nyxo’s poisoning was meant as “a very clear message” to Gabriel, Downey said. “It’s reflective of an industry that is unchecked and has no moral compass,” he said. “There’s no regard for life.”
Daniel Blumstein, chairman of the University of California, Los Angeles’ department of ecology and evolutionary biology, said risk management is a fact of life for field scientists. “There’s a growing list of environmentalists and researchers who have been killed by going public with something, going back to Dian Fossey, saving gorillas in Rwanda,” he said.
“It takes a special person to go out and begin reporting these things,” said Blumstein, who did graduate work in northern Pakistan. “I personally would not like to be messing with drug cartels. There are risks that are too great.”
After Nyxo’s death, anonymous commenters on local websites charged that Gabriel had poisoned his own pet. They said he was a “stooge” working for law enforcement.
His colleagues warned him to be careful. “Some friends and law enforcement said, ‘Hide and be quiet. Look what happened to your dog,’ ” Gabriel said.
“Others said, ‘Maybe you should let people know about what happened.’ This is scientific intimidation. If you are quiet, then they’ve intimidated you.”
Gabriel has cautiously chosen the latter course. He said he’s not trying to be reckless or brave, but he believes that when intimidation has a chilling effect on science, science loses.
Tearing up at his kitchen table, he said he would continue his work because he believes the public and wild creatures have a right to be safe in nature.
Still, he takes precautions. Gabriel’s home now has professionally installed motion detectors and surveillance cameras.
His laboratory also is rigged with alarms.
Two Sundays ago, a lab alarm went off at 5 a.m.
Someone had broken into the back door. Nothing was taken, Gabriel said, but a desk drawer had been opened.
A neighbor told Gabriel he rushed out after the alarm sounded and saw a tall man in black clothes quickly exit the building.
The man got into an SUV with tinted windows and drove off.