Northwest Voices | Letters to the Editor
South Park slaying: Don't finger mental illness as cause
Posted by Letters editor
Kalebu case highlights importance of treatment
Your coverage of the horrible murder and assault that Isaiah M.K. Kalebu is accused of committing ["Video, DNA trail led police to suspect," page one, July 26] suggests he became competent to stand trial in response to mental-health treatment at Western State Hospital.
Like most people who have severe mental illnesses, Kalebu seems to respond to taking medications. We need to remember that severe mental illness is treatable, and the vast majority of people who have mental illness are not violent. Kalebu's repeated threatening and assaultive behaviors may or may not be related to his mental illness.
-- Perry Wien, Seattle
Don't blame mental illness for all violent crimes
As news stories about the horrific violence Teresa Butz and her partner endured continue ["South Park slaying suspect caught," page one, July 25], we are sure to learn more about the mental-health status of the suspect, Isaiah M.K. Kalebu. While we all want an explanation for why such a heinous crime occurred, it is unlikely to be found with this line of reporting.
The news story, "Study says mental illness alone is no trigger for violence," was published by The Seattle Times Feb. 9 [seattletimes.com, Health]. Many research studies, including the one reported in this news story, find that people with mental illness, without other big risk factors, are no more violent than most people.
It is bewildering then that crime stories routinely report any past or a current diagnoses of mental illness -- implying there is a cause-and-effect relationship between the diagnosis and the crime.
If journalists are looking for possible explanations for violent crimes, they should be spending their time tracking down other attainable facts -- such as whether suspects are abusing drugs or alcohol, are recently divorced or separated, have a parental criminal history or were unemployed in the last year, as researchers have found these to be better predictors of violence than a diagnosis of mental illness.
It is time to examine why mental illness has become a scapegoat to explain violent crimes. Is it further evidence of the stigma and discrimination people with mental illness endure or a lack of education that perpetuates the myth?
-- Jennifer Stuber, Seattle
Copyright © 2009 The Seattle Times Company
Feb 21 - 7:00 AM Sen. Patty Murray plans to reintroduce Wild Olympics bill
Feb 21 - 7:00 AM Gun bill allows for police inspection
Feb 21 - 7:00 AM President Obama's early childhood education expansion proposal
Feb 21 - 7:00 AM Don't restrict public's right to access information
Feb 20 - 4:00 PM Lake Burien: public, but private