Skip to main content
Advertising

Originally published August 25, 2014 at 8:21 PM | Page modified August 26, 2014 at 3:48 PM

  • Share:
             
  • Comments
  • Print

Corrected version

South Africa’s AIDS progress in peril

South Africa owes much of its surprising success to a U.S. program begun in 2003 under President George W. Bush. With limited American aid money now being shifted to poorer countries, the nation is left with a growing caseload and a need to find hundreds of millions of dollars.


The New York Times

advertising

VERVENA, South Africa — A fading roadside ad for Selala Funeral Service here captures what was, until recently, the essence of South Africa’s AIDS epidemic: “Tombstones Are Available,” it reads. “Buy One, Get One Free.”

Not long ago, even places like Vervena, a blip on the roadside northeast of Pretoria, supported several funeral parlors.

But in the past few years, “we’ve managed a miracle,” said Dr. Salim Abdool Karim, one of the country’s leading AIDS researchers. “Undertaking is not a business you want to go into anymore.”

As recently as 2008, the AIDS epidemic in South Africa was out of control, hampered by the indifference of President Thabo Mbeki, Nelson Mandela’s successor. Death was everywhere.

Now the country has won high praise from world AIDS experts for its response, especially at a time when the Ebola virus has spread in West Africa.

South Africa has 2.4 million people on antiretroviral drugs, far more than any other country, and adds 100,000 each month. Five years ago, 490 clinics gave out those drugs; now 3,540 do. Only 250 nurses were trained to prescribe them then; now 23,000 are. (The figures, from the end of 2013, are the most recent available.)

Mother-to-child transmissions have dropped by 90 percent, new infections have dropped by a third, and life expectancy has increased by almost 10 years.

“South Africa takes this very seriously and has made major, major progress,” said Michel Sidibé, the executive director of Unaids, the United Nations agency fighting the disease.

But experts say much of that progress is now in jeopardy.

Though few Americans or even South Africans realize it, the nation owes much of its success to a single United States program, the President’s Emergency Plan for AIDS Relief, or PEPFAR, started in 2003 under President George W. Bush. It has poured more than $3 billion into South Africa, largely for training doctors, building clinics and laboratories, and buying drugs.

Now that aid pipeline is drying up as the program shifts its limited budget to poorer countries, so the South African government must find hundreds of millions of dollars, even as its national caseload grows rapidly.

The country has 6 million infected and 370,000 new infections a year. That is seven times as many new infections as in the United States, which has six times the population. Condom use is dropping, according to a new survey, and teenage girls are becoming infected at alarming rates.

Still, Dr. Aaron Motsoaledi, the national health minister, says he is confident South Africa will find the money and the political will to fight on.

“It’s a logistical problem,” he said. “Any country in the world would be shaken by putting 2.4 million people on treatment quickly. But it’s not as if we have any choice. If we don’t, they fill up the hospital beds and ICUs. It’s becoming easier for Treasury to give me what I ask.”

Dr. Ian Sanne’s Right to Care chain of clinics, which treats 203,000 patients in five provinces, is an example of the fruits of American largess.

In a country where public hospitals use hand-scribbled paper records and are infamous for long waits, Right to Care’s Johannesburg headquarters has an electronic medical-records system so fast that a nurse can read a tuberculosis test result delivered by a $17,000 GeneXpert machine and click a box that types a prescription directly into the patient’s record. Within 17 seconds, a German-made robotic arm in the clinic’s pharmacy can pluck that drug from the shelf, print a label, and drop it down a chute to be handed to the patient.

“We opened in 2004, with 100 percent PEPFAR money,” Sanne said.

Right to Care, like many other AIDS treatment programs here, owes its existence to a decision that year by PEPFAR to help South Africa quietly, almost clandestinely, while the Mbeki administration was still in power.

In poor countries with broken health-care systems, PEPFAR paid American medical schools to run its programs. South Africa, by contrast, had excellent doctors and hospitals, but Mbeki’s health minister, who claimed garlic, beetroot and lemons could cure AIDS, forbade public hospitals to give out AIDS drugs.

Mbeki was finally ousted in an internal African National Congress (ANC) power struggle in 2008; by that time, Harvard researchers calculated, his policies had cost 365,000 lives.

Because South Africans are sensitive about needing any foreign help, the aid is still given with little fanfare. Many clinics have only one sign of their roots: a modest brass plaque with PEPFAR’s globe-and-red-ribbon logo.

“I’ve had visiting congressional delegations upset that America gets no recognition for saving lives while China gets visibility for building an airport in Mozambique,” said Dr. Helen Rees of the Wits Reproductive Health Institute in Johannesburg.

South Africa received $350 million from PEPFAR last year, according to Dr. Eric Goosby, who ran the program until last November. That figure will shrink to $250 million by 2016.

“We need to move on to places like Burundi and Cameroon,” Goosby said.

While very poor countries rely almost entirely on donors, South Africa now pays 83 percent of its own costs. But it struggles to do so. Patients overwhelm understaffed public clinics. And as evidence mounts that it is best to put patients on drugs as soon as they test positive rather than waiting until their immune systems falter, the national caseload will triple.

Sanne complained bitterly about cutbacks, Goosby said, and got “bridge money” to prevent layoffs from his well-trained staff.

“Our stay of execution,” Sanne said, laughing.

Closing private clinics can have dangerous consequences. When one Durban hospital abruptly went bankrupt after its PEPFAR grant expired, its 4,000 HIV patients were told to report to public clinics near their homes — places that many HIV patients avoid for fear of being spotted and shunned by their neighbors.

A Harvard-sponsored survey found that nearly 20 percent of those 4,000 patients did not renew their prescriptions at their local clinics.

In theory, because PEPFAR pays for the care of about a million South African patients, a similar dropout rate nationally would mean that 200,000 patients were not in care and were at risk of developing drug-resistant strains, said Matthew M. Kavanagh, the author of a study of South Africa for Health GAP, an American medical advocacy group.

Motsoaledi, South Africa’s health minister since 2009, has won high praise from AIDS experts and even from advocacy groups that are often at odds with him.

Asked if there was any chance that the United States, having received little credit for helping from 2004 on, would now be vilified for pulling out, he said: “No, I personally will never allow that. Because this would never have happened without America.”

Information in this article, originally published Aug. 26, 2014, was corrected Aug. 27, 2014. A quotation in a previous version of this story gave an incomplete name for the speaker: Dr. Helen Rees, of the Wits Reproductive Health Institute in Johannesburg.



Want unlimited access to seattletimes.com? Subscribe now!

News where, when and how you want it

Email Icon

The Seattle Times Historical Archives

Browse our newspaper page archives from 1900-1984


Advertising
The Seattle Times

The door is closed, but it's not locked.

Take a minute to subscribe and continue to enjoy The Seattle Times for as little as 99 cents a week.

Subscription options ►

Already a subscriber?

We've got good news for you. Unlimited seattletimes.com content access is included with most subscriptions.

Subscriber login ►
The Seattle Times

To keep reading, you need a subscription upgrade.

We hope you have enjoyed your complimentary access. For unlimited seattletimes.com access, please upgrade your digital subscription.

Call customer service at 1.800.542.0820 for assistance with your upgrade or questions about your subscriber status.

The Seattle Times

To keep reading, you need a subscription.

We hope you have enjoyed your complimentary access. Subscribe now for unlimited access!

Subscription options ►

Already a subscriber?

We've got good news for you. Unlimited seattletimes.com content access is included with most subscriptions.

Activate Subscriber Account ►