Skip to main content
Advertising

Originally published Saturday, March 1, 2014 at 6:15 AM

  • Share:
             
  • Comments (0)
  • Print

Some antibacterials’ silver lining could have dark side

Capitalizing on public fear of germs, companies are adding tiny silver particles to cutting boards, underwear and an expanding array of other “antibacterial” goods. But some scientists and watchdog groups say widespread use of nanosilver may pose risks to human health or the ecosystem


Chicago Tribune

Most Popular Comments
Hide / Show comments
No comments have been posted to this article.
Start the conversation >

advertising

CHICAGO — Silver has long been known for its ability to kill some nasty microbes that can make people sick. In hospitals, it’s used to help burn victims, to combat germs on catheters and even to wipe out “superbugs” that have grown resistant to traditional antibiotics.

Now, capitalizing on public fear of germs, companies are adding tiny, powerful silver particles to cutting boards, underwear, yoga mats, running shirts, socks and an expanding array of other “antibacterial” goods.

Such products are made possible by advances in technology that allow manufacturers to create nano-sized silver and incorporate it into various materials. (A nanometer is one-billionth of a meter; a human hair is about 80,000 to 100,000 nanometers wide.)

But some scientists and environmental groups say putting nanosilver to widespread use may pose risks, as no one knows how chronic exposure may affect health or the ecosystem in the long run.

They also worry that silver may lose its power to fight infections if bacteria become more resistant, a phenomenon already seen with antibiotic drugs and with triclosan, an ingredient added to antibacterial soaps, cosmetics and other commercial goods.

“Some humans are quite frightened of bacteria, and the tendency to overuse silver is likely,” said Samuel Luoma, an emeritus researcher with the U.S. Geological Survey and the author of “Silver Nanotechnologies and the Environment,” a report published by the Pew Project on Emerging Nanotechnologies.

“What concerns me is the explosion of products which we don’t know are effective and that are not necessary,” Luoma said. “It’s important to prove it’s worth taking the risk before we put it in the environment.”

The Environmental Protection Agency recently began requiring manufacturers of nanosilver to register their products, saying the particles could pose different risks than conventional silver.

But critics, including the Natural Resources Defense Council, say the agency’s process is flawed because it allows the products to be sold commercially several years before safety studies are completed.

Consumers, meanwhile, often can’t tell whether products contain nano-sized silver because nanomaterials aren’t required to be labeled.

“The presence of nanotechnology in consumer products has gone underground,” said Emma Fauss, who in 2008 compiled an inventory of commercial nanotechnology products for the Pew project. “Manufacturers shy away from labeling things in their products unless it’s trendy. There’s a perception that if it’s labeled, it could be dangerous.”

Silver kills germs when it oxidizes and releases silver ions, which are lethal to bacteria and yeast. Ancient civilizations used the metal to treat open wounds.

Nanoparticles of silver, which can occur naturally, are more powerful than bigger particles because their large surface area relative to their mass increases the number of ions released.

The silver industry says concerns about nanosilver are unfounded, pointing to silver’s history as an effective antibiotic agent and noting that most applications use very small quantities. It also says nano-sized silver has been in continual use for more than a century. The products have been safely used in swimming pools and drinking-water purification since the 1970s, said Rosalind Volpe, executive director of the Silver Nanotechnology Working Group.

“It’s the most sustainable and by now the most researched and safest biocide technology on the market,” said Carlo Centonze, CEO of the Swiss company HeiQ, which produces nano-sized silver, primarily for medical products.

Some manufacturers also argue that treating textiles with silver nanoparticles benefits the environment by reducing the need for washing, allowing cleaning at lower temperatures and making the products more durable.

In general, experts agree that humans can safely tolerate fairly high doses of silver. What’s new is that over the past decade nanoparticles have been manipulated and put in places where silver has never been before.

Some scientists and environmental groups fear that the very properties that make these particles useful — their vanishingly small size and high surface area — may have unintended consequences once they get into the human body and the environment.

Both animal studies and computer models have found that nanoparticles, including nanosilver, can spread throughout the body into organs and tissues.

“Nanoparticles are little bundles of pure metal that can dissolve within the body if taken up as a particle,” said Luoma. “To me,” he added, “the big risk is to ingest or breathe nanosilver when we don’t know for sure if there’s a unique risk in this form.”

Like other germ-killers, including antibiotics, nanosilver also could upset the delicate balance of bacteria inside the digestive tract, said Marina Quadros, associate director of the Virginia Tech Center for Sustainable Nanotechnology. “Under the right conditions, silver nanoparticles are very effective in killing bacteria, both the good and the bad,” she said.

Beyond the possible impact of nanosilver on human health, environmental concerns loom large.

“There is clear evidence that silver, and in particular nanosilver, is toxic to aquatic and terrestrial organisms” and to cells from mammals in laboratory research, the EPA stated in a 2010 report.

Potential sources of nanosilver pollution include landfills, wastewater-treatment plants and industrial facilities. Several lab studies also have found that nanosilver can leach out of products when washed.

“If we start using tons of silver nanoparticles and a lot more are going down the drain, then we might start to have an effect we haven’t seen in the past,” said Amy Pruden, a professor of civil and environmental engineering at Virginia Tech who is investigating whether silver nanoparticles in waste streams can stimulate antibiotic resistance in microbes.



News where, when and how you want it

Email Icon

Enter to win!

Enter to win!

Share a photo of your holiday lights display and you may win a $100 Home Depot gift card.

Advertising

Partner Video

Advertising

Career Center Blog

Career Center Blog

Looking for joy on the job


Advertising
The Seattle Times

The door is closed, but it's not locked.

Take a minute to subscribe and continue to enjoy The Seattle Times for as little as 99 cents a week.

Subscription options ►

Already a subscriber?

We've got good news for you. Unlimited seattletimes.com content access is included with most subscriptions.

Subscriber login ►