Immigrant’s death in Israeli prison cloaked in mystery
It is not known why, in early 2010, Israeli security agents detained Ben Zygier and sent him to solitary confinement in a notorious Israeli prison where even his jailers didn’t know who he was or why he was there.
TEL AVIV, Israel —
A few facts are known about Ben Zygier: He was born Sept. 12, 1976, in Melbourne, Australia, and he died in Israel on Dec. 15, 2010. In between, he was involved in a number of Jewish organizations, immigrated to Israel in his early 20s, married an Israeli woman and fathered two children. He returned to Australia in 2009 to pursue an MBA.
What’s not known is why, in early 2010, Israeli security agents detained him — it’s not clear where — and sent him to solitary confinement in a notorious prison where even his jailers didn’t know who he was or why he was there.
Nor is it known how, under 24-hour surveillance in a suicide-proof cell, he managed to hang himself.
Israelis wonder what Zygier possibly could have done to earn what turned out to be a life sentence in Israel’s Ayalon prison, the country’s highest-security lockup.
His existence became public only upon his death, when an Israeli news website briefly ran an article stating that an inmate at Ayalon, identified only as Prisoner X, had committed suicide.
But that information was quickly put under a censorship order so severe that even mentioning the order itself was forbidden.
The veil finally was lifted Wednesday, when Israeli newspapers were allowed to quote an investigative report by the Australian Broadcasting Corp.
Since then, a few more facts have emerged: Zygier was a member of Israel’s Mossad spy agency. He had multiple identities, including Ben Alon, Ben Allen and Benjamin Burrows.
Friends who remember him in Israel said they called him Benjy, and he was mostly “a friendly guy, who liked to have a chat.”
“He was always keeping up with everything going on around him. He read all the papers and had an opinion about them,” said one Israeli who’d served with Zygier in a combat unit. He refused to give his name or the year of his service out of fear he’d be punished for speaking about the sensitive case.
“Everyone is freaked out,” he said. “I mean, I really don’t know anything sensitive or special about him, but the other guys in the unit are all wondering what the hell he could have done. He seemed like a pretty normal guy.”
Another friend, who had attended Zygier’s wedding, said there have been “rumors and jokes” that he was a Mossad agent because of his frequent trips abroad and obsession with Middle Eastern politics.
“It was something a few people suspected or whispered about, but it wasn’t really serious. We didn’t think he was some James Bond or anything,” he said, also asking to be quoted anonymously.
Israel’s Justice Ministry released a statement Wednesday evening acknowledging the existence of “Prisoner X” for the first time, though it stopped short of naming him.
It assured Israelis that whatever Prisoner X had done, due process had been observed at every step: “His family was notified of the arrest immediately. ... The prisoner was held by proxy of an arrest warrant issued by the court. ... He was duly represented in all the proceedings against him by attorneys.”
The statement concluded: “National security prevents the release of any other details in this case. These aspects of national security have been reviewed by the Central District Court, which decided to impose a comprehensive gag order on the case.”
Zygier’s family, including his wife in Israel, have refused to speak to reporters and said they wanted to be left alone.
In one of the few pictures posted online of his wife and two children, a caption from December read, “Finally, in happier times.” Israeli reporters have kept the wife’s identity secret to protect the family’s privacy.
His family in Australia was said to have been “devastated” by his death. His parents, who’d worked as Jewish community organizers in Melbourne, quit their jobs shortly after he died. Australian papers said the family had completely withdrawn after the funeral, and the once-active members of the community are now rarely seen.
Suspicions in Australia
What could Zygier have done to frighten his family and Israel into utmost secrecy?
The Australian newspaper The Age ran a report Wednesday saying that at the time of his death, Zygier was under investigation by the Australian Security Intelligence Organization, which suspected him of using his Australian passport to spy for Israel.
The newspaper said he was one of several individuals who’d raised suspicion by asking for new passports with more “Anglo”-sounding names after they’d immigrated to Israel.
“The men had used the new passports to travel to Iran, Syria and Lebanon — all countries that do not recognize Israel and do not allow entry to Israelis, or anyone with an Israeli stamp in their passport,” the newspaper said.
The Mossad has long relied on Jewish immigrants with foreign passports. One former Mossad agent recalled in an interview last year that it often recruited immigrants from “attractive Western countries” as agents if they were deemed to have appropriate “profiles.”
The former agent, who agreed to talk in general about Mossad recruitment of foreigners only if his identity remained secret, said such recruits might be assigned to a wide variety of tasks.
Some were asked to use passports to rent apartments or purchase cars in foreign countries, he said. Others might become more active members who undertook delicate international missions.
It’s unclear what role Zygier had in the Mossad. Various theories have suggested he was a double agent, that he’d been caught using his Australian passport to spy for Israel and was being pressed to spy for Australia as well.
Other reports have speculated he was caught selling secrets to the Iranians or one of Israel’s other regional enemies.
“He did something that went to the highest level of state security and which required him being kept alive but in absolute isolation. That is all I can tell you,” said one senior Israeli defense official, who said he was privy to some details but couldn’t say more. He asked that he not be identified.
Officials at Ayalon prison, where Zygier spent nearly a year in isolation, refused to comment.
Zygier was kept in a cell known as Wing 15 that had been designed for Yigal Amir, who assassinated Prime Minister Yitzhak Rabin. Ari Shamay, a lawyer for Amir who visited him once in the cell, described it as a “four-by-four room, with next to nothing inside but a bed, shower and toilet.”
Cameras were fixed on the room and monitored 24 hours a day. Reports in Israeli newspapers have said the room had special sensors that monitored temperature and even heartbeat, though Israeli officials wouldn’t confirm those details.
Israeli human-rights groups have begun asking how, under those conditions, a prisoner managed to fashion a noose and hang himself.
On Wednesday, Israeli blogs speculated that the suicide story was another cover-up, designed to disguise a more gruesome death.
In the end, they concluded, Zygier may have taken his secrets with him to the grave.
Australian Foreign Minister Bob Carr, meanwhile, said he would review his department’s handling of the arrest and death of Zygier, 34.
Australian officials are under fire for failing to do more to assist Zygier after he was arrested and to inquire into the circumstances of his death.
In 2010, Mossad was accused of using foreign passports in an elaborate undercover operation to assassinate Hamas operative Mahmoud al-Mabhouh in a Dubai hotel room.
Much of the operation was captured on surveillance cameras, triggering an international backlash against Israel from those nations whose passports had been used, including Australia.
Material from the Los Angeles Times is included in this report.