Skip to main content
Advertising

Originally published July 6, 2012 at 10:05 PM | Page modified July 6, 2012 at 10:12 PM

  • Share:
           
  • Comments (261)
  • Print

Weak jobs reports expected into fall — a problem for Obama

The lackluster jobs report is not likely to help President Obama's re-election prospects.

The New York Times

Most Popular Comments
Hide / Show comments
Obamanation the radical, the jobs killer strikes again...Folks this is really simple:... MORE
Obama is an unprecedented failure - especially on the economy. I don't understand how... MORE
3.5 years of bad policy has bought us to this. There is no reason to reelect this man. MORE

advertising

It is increasingly apparent what the economy will look like when President Obama faces voters in November: pretty much what it looks like today.

That picture, a report from the Labor Department made clear Friday, is far from the booming job growth that prevailed only a few months ago. In June, the economy added a meager 80,000 jobs, and the unemployment rate remained at 8.2 percent.

Early this year optimists buzzed that the jobless rate might slip below 8 percent by the election, a major symbolic victory for the incumbent. Then employment growth slowed in March and took a turn toward the paltry in April and May.

With Friday's report, what looked like a blip has become a streak. And with a gridlocked Congress unlikely to pass any additional stimulus measures before the election, the president is stuck again with an economy in stall mode.

June's job growth, after a revised increase of 77,000 in May, was just about enough to keep up with population growth but not nearly enough to reduce the backlog of 13 million workers.

Since most economists have been forecasting a slower second half of 2012 because of electioneering and a congressional fight over extending expiring tax cuts, there's little momentum heading into an anticipated rough patch.

And that could prove to be bad news for the president's hopes for another four years in office.

"In the end, these presidential elections tend to be a referendum on the incumbent president," said Sarah Binder, a political-science professor at George Washington University. "The bulk of voters' decisions come down to the state of the national economy."

Binder said that even if the economy came roaring back after Labor Day, it might be too late to help Obama.

"Some of it's already baked in," she said.

Economists expect continued sluggishness.

"This economy has no forward momentum and little help from monetary or fiscal policy," said Kathy Bostjancic, director of macroeconomic analysis for The Conference Board. "As if that were not enough, ill winds are blowing in from both a contracting Europe and slowing growth in emerging markets.

Friday's report also put a chill on financial markets, sending stocks sharply lower on both sides of the Atlantic.

At a campaign stop in Poland, Ohio, on Friday, Obama urged voters to take the long view and to be mindful of the economic state he inherited.

"I want to get back to a time when middle-class families and those working to get into the middle class have some basic security," he said. "We've got to deal with what's been happening over the last decade, the last 15 years."

Mitt Romney, Obama's presumed presidential challenger, emphasized the more recent string of weak job growth that has taken place under Obama's leadership.

"This is a time for Americans to choose whether they want more of the same," Romney said from Wolfeboro, N.H., where he is vacationing. "It doesn't have to be this way. America can do better. And this kick in the gut has to end."

The recent string of weak employment growth may work to political advantage for Romney.

From December through February, private companies added an average of 252,000 workers a month. But job growth slowed in March, leading some economists to wonder whether the unseasonably warm winter, rather than a fundamentally healthier economy, had been the real source of the short-lived employment surge.

"The net of it is not as if the economy is collapsing, but it wasn't really as strong as it looked in December, January and February," said Jim O'Sullivan, U.S. economist at High Frequency Economics.

The numbers themselves are also adjusted for seasonality, and these adjustments themselves can be imprecise and open to interpretation.

One of the few industries with decent job growth was temporary-help services, suggesting that employers are not confident enough of the recovery's sustainability to invest in permanent hires even if their order books are growing.

Among the few bright spots in Friday's report were ticks upward in average hourly earnings (to $23.50, from $23.44 in May) and the length of the typical private-sector workweek (34.5 hours, from 34.4).

Still, the overall weakness in the report may have nudged Federal Reserve officials toward additional monetary stimulus.

"The odds of QE3 happening before the election are clearly going up," said Jay Feldman, an economist at Credit Suisse, referring to the nickname for a third round of stimulus known as quantitative easing.

The Fed has been reluctant to inject more money, partly because it has been hard to determine whether additional monetary stimulus is either effective or even needed.

Since the recovery officially began in June 2009, there have been several spates of promising job growth, which raised hopes of a strengthening recovery that were ultimately dashed. Each time economists attributed the hiring slowdown to one-time negative shocks, including last year's tsunami in Japan and the Arab Spring uprisings.

A healthier economy might have been able to withstand such shocks easily, but not one weakened by a debt overhang and sea of underwater homes.

"At this point, expectations are pretty low, so anything that is moving the job market in the right direction would be welcome," said Sophia Koropeckyj, managing director at Moody's Analytics.

Economists worry that even modest acceleration in job growth could be derailed by additional shocks abroad and at home.

While there are challenges across the developing world, including China, the primary foreign drag on the U.S. economy is coming from Europe's protracted sovereign debt crisis.

"When you factor in the effect on U.S. trade, financial markets and credit availability, the Europe crisis is probably taking a percentage point off of U.S. growth," said Andrew Tilton, a senior U.S. economist at Goldman Sachs, of Europe's impact on the United States' gross domestic product.

There are plenty of homegrown risks, too.

Struggling local governments have been shedding workers. There was a brief respite in June, but economists generally seem to expect the layoffs to pick up again for the rest of the year.

Material from

McClatchy Newspapers

is included in this report.

News where, when and how you want it

Email Icon

Career Center Blog

Career Center Blog

Bad email habits to break today


Advertising