Originally published March 15, 2011 at 9:23 PM | Page modified March 16, 2011 at 6:55 AM
Comments (0)
E-mail article
Print
Share
How bad is disaster? Chernobyl was worse
The IAEA rated the seriousness of the nuclear emergency at the Fukushima Daiichi reactors as 6 on a scale of 7. Three Mile Island was rated as 5/7, while Chernobyl was rated 7/7.
The International Atomic Energy Agency (IAEA) on Tuesday rated the seriousness of the nuclear emergency at the Fukushima Daiichi reactors as 6 on a scale of 7.
Three Mile Island was rated as 5/7, while Chernobyl was rated 7/7.
Here's a comparison of the three nuclear emergencies:
Chernobyl
Where: Near Kiev, Ukraine
When: April 26, 1986
Scale of accident: 7 out of 7
Cause: Human error. Workers conducting a test had switched off important control systems at the plant's reactor 4 and allowed it to reach unstable, low-power conditions, according to a United Nations report.
What happened: Explosions blew the roof off the reactor and vaporized its radioactive fuel, unleashing a radiation cloud that swept across Europe and around the world. The blasts occurred while the reactor was operating at full temperature, adding energy to the explosion. Far more radioactive material was blasted, and dangerous levels were found as far as 600 miles away.
Casualties: Estimates vary widely. While fewer than 100 deaths were directly attributed to the disaster as of 2009, Ukraine's health ministry estimated 3.5 million people have suffered some illness as a result of the contamination, and the Ukraine Radiological Institute suggested there were 2,500 deaths. Some environmental groups say up to 500,000 people have died from the effects of radiation.
Government reaction: The disaster was not revealed by Soviet authorities until two days later, after nuclear technicians in Sweden discovered the radiation.
Aftermath: Officials say it could be up to 100 years before the station is completely decommissioned. A temporary "sarcophagus" covering the reactor is showing signs of decay. A 19-mile exclusion zone is in place round the site.
![]()
Three Mile Island
Where: near Harrisburg, Pa.
When: March 28, 1979
Scale of accident: 5 out of 7
Cause: A combination of personnel error, design deficiencies and component failures.
What happened: Operators trying to unclog some piping in the steam-generating water circulation system accidentally blocked the flow of water, causing heat to build in the reactor. A gradual loss of water to cool the reactor's core led to partial melting of the fuel-rod cladding and the uranium fuel, and a small amount of radioactive gas was released.
Casualties: No deaths or illnesses.
Government reaction: Sweeping changes were made, including more emergency-response planning, increased operator training and heightened regulatory oversight.
Fukushima Daiichi
Where: Japan (135 miles north of Tokyo)
When: March 11, 2011
Scale of accident: 6 out of 7
Cause: Earthquake and tsunami cut power to the plant, crippling cooling systems needed to keep nuclear fuel from melting down.
What happened: Three reactor units suffered explosions. Some radiation was released, and officials believe a partial meltdown has occurred in at least two units.
Casualties: Unknown.
Government reaction: About 185,000 residents within a 12-mile radius of the plant were told to evacuate the area, and about 140,000 residents living from 12 to 19 miles from the plant were warned to seal themselves indoors.
Sources: International Atomic Energy Agency, BBC, Time and Seattle Times news services

Entertainment | Top Video | World | Offbeat Video | Sci-Tech
general classifieds
Garage & estate salesFurniture & home furnishings
Electronics
just listed
More listings
POST A FREE LISTING
- Seattle’s NBA hopes still high as league warms to expansion
- China’s wealthy paying cash for Eastside luxury homes
- Sex-with-animals advocate told to stay off Internet
- Navy dolphins discover rare old torpedo off Calif. coast near Coronado
- Dark, massive asteroid to fly by Earth on May 31
- Review: Despite sleek design, HTC One disappoints
- Man survives bear attack after wife cracks it on head
- An innocent slip of the (long, slinky) tongue by NBA honcho | The Wrap / Ron Judd
- Seattle Sounders knock off FC Dallas, 4-2, to extend unbeaten streak to six
- It’s time to limit presidency to one term | Danny Westneat
- IRS office was perplexed, inundated with tax-exempt applications
249 - Game thread: Felix Hernandez looks to halt Mariners skid
187 - Mariners seeing what that crucial speed element looks like
177 - Seattle’s NBA hopes still high as league warms to expansion
143 - It’s time to limit presidency to one term
111 - Premiums under new health-care law remain about the same
111 - China’s wealthy paying cash for Eastside luxury homes
105 - Aide: Obama learned about IRS from news accounts
58 - Tea party looks to take advantage of moment
24 - C.J. Wilcox undergoes surgery
22
- China’s wealthy paying cash for Eastside luxury homes
- Columbia Hills State Park is a Gorge wonder
- Premiums under new health-care law remain about the same
- 129 concerts to see this summer
- Fremont: Quirky, lively and very popular | NW Neighborhood
- Diversity means opportunity in Tukwila
- The stories behind Huntington’s disease | Nicole & Co.
- Navy dolphins discover rare old torpedo off Calif. coast near Coronado
- Sex-with-animals advocate told to stay off Internet
- Cancer survivor exudes calm in Legislature’s budget battles

News where, when and how you want it
All newsletters Privacy statement