Advertising

The Seattle Times Company

NWjobs | NWautos | NWhomes | NWsource | Free Classifieds | seattletimes.com

Nation & World


Our network sites seattletimes.com | Advanced

Originally published Sunday, November 9, 2008 at 12:00 AM

Comments (0)     Print

States find dialysis for illegal immigrants a costly dilemma

Roughly 2,000 times over the past 17 years, Marguerita Toribio, an illegal immigrant from Mexico, has climbed into a cushioned recliner for the three-hour dialysis treatment that keeps her alive.

Los Angeles Times

Roughly 2,000 times over the past 17 years, Marguerita Toribio, an illegal immigrant from Mexico, has climbed into a cushioned recliner for the three-hour dialysis treatment that keeps her alive.

She has never seen a bill.

U.S. taxpayers have covered the entire cost of her treatment in California: more than $500,000 and rising, not including a kidney transplant in 1993.

The kidney failed when Toribio briefly moved to North Carolina, which refused to pay for her anti-rejection drugs. She needed to go back on dialysis three days a week to clear toxins from her blood, but North Carolina didn't cover that, either.

The best a social worker could offer was a prepaid plane ticket back to California.

"When I came back here, I said, 'There is no way I'm leaving for another state again,' " said Toribio, now 29, before a technician poked two needles into her arm at the St. Joseph Hospital dialysis center in Orange, Calif.

Health services and other benefits available to illegal immigrants can vary by the state. Welfare, prenatal care or in-state college tuition might be available in one place and inaccessible across a state line.

The disparities reflect the nation's conflicting attitudes toward its estimated 12 million illegal immigrants. With limited federal guidance, states often are left to make their own decisions, frequently shaped by political winds.

Dialysis offers a striking example of the dilemmas — and the occasional absurdities — that result.

The number of patients is not large. In California, illegal immigrants account for about 1,350 of the 61,000 people on dialysis. Their treatment cost taxpayers $51 million last year.

But dialysis stands out because it is often a lifetime commitment. The investment in a can easily top $1 million over time.

Many states draw the line at illegal immigrants. But officials in California, New York and a few other states figure that not treating patients costs even more.

advertising

That is because patients without regular dialysis frequently end up in emergency rooms. At that point, federal law requires they receive dialysis until they are stable enough to be released — usually only to deteriorate within weeks and return to the ER.

It's like "rescuing a person from drowning, giving someone a good meal and then pushing them over the side," said Dr. Laurence Lewin, a kidney specialist in Orange County, Calif.

Repeated rescuing not only threatens patients' long-term health, it generally costs more than routine care, some experts argue.

In Texas, where illegal immigrants generally can't get routine care, some have cycled through the emergency room at El Paso's Thomason Hospital more than 100 times for lifesaving dialysis, said kidney specialist Dr. Azikiwe Nwosu.

Such patients are at increased risk of heart attacks and infections.

"It's heartbreaking," said Dr. Claudia Zacharek, a kidney specialist who until recently worked in Galveston, Texas. "Your hands are tied."

Opting for treatment

In grappling with what services to provide for illegal immigrants, some states tip toward the need to care for the sick. Others see free health care as a de-facto endorsement of their presence.

Congress tried to establish a balance. In 1986, it barred illegal immigrants from the federal health benefits generally available to the poor, with one notable exception: emergencies. The federal government agreed to share the cost of caring for poor illegal immigrants through state-run Emergency Medicaid programs.

The problem is the federal definition of an emergency is open to interpretation: an acute condition that, without immediate care, would seriously jeopardize a patient's health or impair bodily functions, parts or organs.

Debates have flared over chemotherapy, life-support and dialysis. In 2002, Sen. John McCain, R-Ariz., co-sponsored a bill to provide dialysis and other chronic care needed to prevent expensive ER visits.

It failed. What's left is an ambiguous policy the federal government has struggled to clarify.

"We do not pay for chronic care for illegal immigrants," Mary Kahn, a Medicaid spokeswoman, said when asked about the issue in 2007.

If California and other states were using federal funds to help provide routine dialysis, she said, they were mischaracterizing it as an emergency treatment.

More recently, she acknowledged the federal government has been sharing the cost in California for years. It has long been left to the states to decide whether to provide routine dialysis, she said.

Not an emergency

Many states, including Texas, Colorado and New Mexico, take the position that kidney failure does not automatically qualify as an emergency because patients can survive for weeks without dialysis before toxins accumulate to fatal levels.

Other states have wavered. North Carolina, for example, now provides routine dialysis for illegal immigrants. Conversely, the Georgia Medicaid program stopped paying for dialysis in 2006 amid rising sentiments in the Legislature that illegal immigrants were a financial drain.

The courts haven't cleared up the issue.

A group of illegal immigrants sued Arizona in 2002 after the state attempted to cut off their dialysis. Heeding arguments that sporadic emergency treatments would jeopardize lives, a judge told the state to keep treating them while the case was decided.

In a settlement last year, the state agreed to restore its policy of providing routine dialysis, but the settlement applies only to Arizona.

California's dialysis policy is largely an economic calculation, said Stan Rosenstein, the administrator of Medi-Cal, the state health-care program for the poor.

The cost of one routine treatment is about $250. The cost of providing it in the emergency room can climb into the thousands of dollars.

Missing the point

To advocates of stricter immigration controls, such comparisons miss the point.

"Taxpayers are on the hook for people who aren't supposed to be here," said Mark Krikorian, executive director of the Center for Immigration Studies.

The fear in many states is that offering routine dialysis will lure more sick people from other countries.

"We cannot provide dialysis to the world," said Ramiro Valdez, a Dallas social worker and medical consultant.

Teresita Aquino, an undocumented immigrant from the Philippines, hadn't intended to stay in the United States, but being rushed to the emergency room with kidney failure eight years ago changed her mind. Now, a free transportation service picks her up three days a week for her dialysis in Torrance, Calif.

"If I go home, I won't be able to afford this," said Aquino, 56. "No way am I going home."

The only alternative to dialysis is a kidney transplant, a procedure California and a few other states provide to illegal immigrants. Last year, 52 of the 1,912 kidney transplants in California were for illegal immigrants.

Several studies show that a transplant pays for itself in three dialysis-free years. Critics, however, say that dipping into the organ pool is a greater outrage because so many citizens are waiting.

"It's not like you go to Costco and pick up a kidney," Krikorian said.

Toribio is now seeking a second transplant.

She said she is grateful for the care she has received in California. But Toribio, who works in a textile factory for $8 an hour attaching tags to blankets, towels and bath mats, believes the United States should accept it as the price of a cheap labor pool.

As much as she would like to visit her parents and grandparents in Mexico, she has never returned.

It is not worth the risk of leaving California: She might not be able to get back.

Copyright © 2008 The Seattle Times Company

More Nation & World headlines...

Print      Share:    Digg     Newsvine

Comments
No comments have been posted to this article.

UPDATE - 10:01 AM
Rebels tighten hold on Libya oil port

UPDATE - 09:29 AM
Reality leads US to temper its tough talk on Libya

UPDATE - 09:38 AM
2 Ark. injection wells may be closed amid quakes

Armed guards save Dutch couple from Somali pirates

Navy to release lewd video investigation findings

Advertising

Video

Marketplace

Lab develops innovative vehicle technologynew
Nestled in the rolling Tennessee hills and forests, the secretive lab that developed power for the Manhattan Project is working to change the auto ind...
Post a comment

Advertising