Skip to main content
Advertising

Originally published July 27, 2013 at 5:30 PM | Page modified August 22, 2013 at 2:21 PM

  • Share:
           
  • Comments (65)
  • Print

Kennewick Man a debate not easily put to rest

Nearly two decades after he was accidentally discovered in one of the biggest archaeological finds of a generation, Kennewick Man is still in limbo.

Seattle Times staff reporter

Most Popular Comments
Hide / Show comments
"The love and care paid to these remains, blessed and returned to earth, is what... MORE
The land bridge based history of the north American Indian population is more than a... MORE
Kennewick Man aka Captain Jean-Luc Picard? http://3.bp.blogspot.com/-8LjIIZ2dOsg/UHp... MORE

advertising

NANEUM, Kittitas County —

Wind sweeps across this lonely stretch of sagebrush, carrying songs and prayers of 10 tribes gathered here, laying ancestral remains to rest.

From both sides of the mountains, they helped bless the bones of 57 individuals wrapped in white cotton muslin tied with cotton string, put away with cedar boughs and tule mats within a hand-dug grave.

Afterward, elder Avery Cleveland of the Confederated Tribes of the Colville Indian Reservation knelt to burn tobacco on the covered grave, sending its smoke and a horse song on the rising wind.

The love and care paid to these remains, blessed and returned to earth, is what tribal leaders say they want to give Kennewick Man. But nearly two decades after one of the oldest and most intact ancient skeletons ever found in North America was accidentally discovered, Kennewick Man, more than 9,500 years old, is still in limbo.

That could be about to change.

Scientists in Copenhagen right now are doing tests using new methods that could for the first time extract some of the skeleton’s DNA, perhaps answering the question of the ancient man’s ancestry.

Tribes that want the skeleton reburied say they are going to try again within a year to change federal law to repatriate ancient remains, including Kennewick Man’s.

And a book that details the findings from years of study of the skeleton should be out, after years of waiting.

The research has urgent relevance. The case for reburial that the tribes lost in court still could be reopened and, depending on findings that emerge, could yet have a very different outcome, including repatriation of the bones to the tribes, said Gail Celmer, regional archaeologist for the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers Northwest Division, in Portland.

Scientists oppose reburial, saying there is still so much more to be learned about Kennewick Man, from just where a stone point in his hip came from, to his ancient diet.

At the heart of the matter is whether the remains can be determined to be of Native American origin, as the tribes insist. If so, federal law requires that the bones be returned for reburial by tribes that claim them.

A federal appeals panel in 2004 found the bones too old, and the context of their find too void of archaeological clues, to assign membership genetically or culturally to any modern tribe.

“If there is information ... that indicates he may be Native American, it might cause us to reopen the analysis,” the panel wrote.

Tribes determined

Five Northwest tribes — Yakama, Colville, Nez Perce, Wanapum and Umatilla — fought in court for reburial under the Native American Graves Protection and Repatriation Act (NAGPRA).

“We know he will come home to us someday. We never give up,” said Rex Buck, spiritual leader of the Wanapum tribe.

The tribes have continued to press their case with the Corps, which controls access to the skeleton because it was found on Corps property. Two boys wading the shallows of the Columbia River in 1996 stumbled upon the skeleton, emerging from the banks near Kennewick, and called the police.

Tribes have fought for repatriation from just about every angle. “We have looked at cemetery laws. We have looked at it as an archaeological collection,” Celmer said. “We have talked about underground curation.

“I am not sure we could guarantee that we could keep it stable or protected, but it is a novel idea.”

It was Buck who last fall invited Doug Owsley, a physical anthropologist at the Smithsonian Institution’s National Museum of Natural History who led the fight in court to study the skeleton, to the Northwest. He did it, Buck said, to hear what Owsley had to say about his research on Kennewick Man so far, and to ask Owsley for his help in getting Kennewick Man back.

Owsley made no such commitment that day. But he did make headlines when he declared Kennewick Man not only isn’t an Indian, but that he’s not from the mid-Columbia at all.

Residue in Kennewick man’s bones showed he ate a lot of food from the marine environment: marine mammals, such as seals, especially, Owsley said in a private gathering with tribal members at Central Washington University.

“They are not what you would expect for someone from the Columbia Valley,” he said of isotopes detected in the remains. “You would have to eat salmon 24 hours a day and you would not reach these values.

“This is a man from the coast. Not a man from here. I think he is a coastal man.”

Buck told Owsley at the time that while he appreciated the presentation, it lacked a larger picture of how tribal members actually live, then and today.

Lamprey eel could have provided the same types of nutrients, Buck noted. “I hope you would think about some of those things too, and add that to your equation.”

It was a gentle reminder of a very different mid-Columbia, teeming with animal life even as recently as some 200 years ago, let alone during the time of Kennewick Man.

Primeval abundance

When Lewis and Clark explored portions of the Columbia and Snake rivers in 1805 and 1806, they remarked in their journals on their amazement at the multitude of animals, including marine mammals, they saw.

Seals and sea lions — not blocked by dams, as they are today — once cruised nearly 200 miles upriver, all the way to what Lewis and Clark called the Great Falls of the Columbia: Celilo Falls.

Salmon, of course, were so plentiful that settlers later harvested them by the truckload to fertilize cleared land for farming. With 11 runs of salmon pushed to the brink of extinction by eight dams on the lower Columbia and Snake Rivers, today it is easy to forget the abundance of salmon that once fed tribes from the saltwater coast to the inland-most reaches of the Columbia watershed more than 900 miles away, said Bill McMillan, who is researching the historic and prehistoric Columbia River Basin ecosystem for NOAA fisheries. “It’s called the shifting baseline syndrome.

“Our vision of what we consider to be abundant is usually from the time period that we have experienced.”

As recently as the 1970s, Oregon fisheries managers were dosing headwater streams with Rotenone to kill off Pacific lamprey, an eel known for high nutritional value and harvested by the tribes since the melting of the glaciers.

“Kennewick Man would have feasted on this animal with a higher omega-3 fatty acid content than any marine mammal,” said Jay Miller, a Seattle anthropologist who has studied the role of lamprey in tribal cultures, which continues today.

The tribes fighting for the return of Kennewick Man have depended on lamprey for some 10,000 years for its fatty meat.

Others take issue

Kennewick Man likely feasted from an abundant land, too, with something to eat in every season, noted Carl Gustafson, retired professor of archaeology from Washington State University. “It really wouldn’t have been a bad world,” Gustafson said.

The landscape of Kennewick Man would have looked much the same as today in the Mid-Columbia. Deer, elk and maybe bison would have been around 9,000 to 10,000 years ago, as well as the plants native people still rely on: biscuitroot, bitterroot, balsamroot and all kinds of lomatiums — wild celery.

Kennewick Man probably would have traveled back and forth over the Cascades for trade, too, as well as for visiting and fun. Mastodon bone rods found in 1987 near Wenatchee at a site dated to 13,800 years ago are believed by tribal members to be carved sticks used to play sla-hal, a gambling game that dates to the tribes’ earliest gatherings.

All that traveling, in gathering food, following trade routes and visiting for social and ceremonial gatherings is one reason that, to anthropologist Darby Stapp, of Richland, Owsley’s flat declaration that Kennewick Man was from the coast is ridiculous.

“The first time I heard him say that it was like, ‘Whoa, where are you coming from with that?’ ” Stapp said.

“We know more than likely people went back and forth in any scenario, but mostly I don’t see why it matters. For me, he could be from the coast, it doesn’t matter; obviously he was here, and I doubt it was for the first time, and the community obviously buried him.”

More fundamentally, he and others doubted the value of findings coming out of research on the skeleton so far, or in the future.

“It’s underwhelming, it’s one individual; you are never going to learn a whole lot about a population from one individual,” Stapp said.

Peter Lape, an archaeologist at the University of Washington, also questioned Owsley’s flat statement that isotopes show Kennewick Man was actually a coastal man.

“Isotopes are very difficult to interpret. There are a lot of issues with calibrating and interpreting them; the best people have many caveats,” Lape said. “He just puts it out there. The audacity of that is stunning; he is so arrogant it is amazing.”

The information so far coming out of the research has been the equivalent of “celebrity gossip,” Lape said. “It’s that his right arm is bigger than the other, but that doesn’t tell us anything about the past, it doesn’t answer those questions, and all these years later we still don’t have published results.”

The Corps of Engineers lost patience with Owsley in April, reprimanding him in a letter for publishing nothing from his research so far beyond a children’s book.

“I find this to be totally unacceptable,” wrote Anthony Funkhouser, then brigadier general and U.S. Army division commander for the Corps.

“You and your colleagues have not produced anything for scientific journals despite your historic position of the collection’s immense value to the scientific community and the general public. That value is only realized when the data and the interpretation of those data are available for scrutiny and discourse.”

Owsley said in a telephone interview he is very aware of the need to finish writing up and publish results from the study, adding that his manuscript will be completed this summer for publication perhaps next year.

The manuscript is in more than 30 chapters. He said it took so long because it is “definitive.”

“People have not seen this level of analysis before,” Owsley said. “ It takes the whole topic of ancient Americans to another level.”

Asked about the book, he said: “At this point I just want to get it done. I don’t want to get into debating.”

Spiritual tradition

Meanwhile, tribal elders say that Kennewick Man having been intentionally buried is proof enough he was part of their community.

“In our way, he could be from Samoa, he could be from anywhere,” said John Sirois, chairman of the Colville Business Council. “But if he married into one of our tribes and took care of a family and fished with us, in our way, he was part of the community, he was part of the people. It was a matter of ‘we are in this together, you are part of this community,’ and to this day, that core element is still in place.

“Taking care of a person and making sure they are returned to earth is part of that cycle of life.”

Vivian Harrison, NAGPRA coordinator for the Yakama Indian Nation, said that it is painful for the Ancient One’s bones to remain unburied.

“Really, to me it’s sad,” Harrison said. “This is a human being, and in our belief, his journey has been interrupted by leaving the ground. It is disturbing to us. My main question here is when will they be finished? When will they let him go so he can return to the ground and finish his journey?”

Real harm is visited on the community when spirits are disturbed in their rest, said Barbara Friedlander Aripa, a Colville elder. She was one of a group of elders who did a ceremony for the Ancient One on the shore after the discovery.

Murders, car wrecks, shootings, accidents, chaos. In tribal teachings, they come from a world of spiritual unrest, she said. “Return him to the people. We want him put in the ground so his soul can rest.”

Attempts to extract and analyze Kennewick Man’s DNA from small pieces of bone taken from the skeleton should not be abandoned, said Dennis Stanford, curator of archaeology and director of the paleoecology program for the Smithsonian.

He is a member of the team publishing his research in Owsley’s book.

Stanford said he realizes not all of the pieces in Kennewick Man’s story are yet adding up.

For instance, he said, while Owsley declared Kennewick Man was from the coast, what then is he doing with a stone point buried in his hip that is associated with the Great Basin or Wenatchee area?

“How do you reconcile that?” Stanford asked. “In order to live on the coast and have that projectile point in him all that time, it doesn’t add up that nicely.”

But to him, that just shows the need for more analysis. While Stanford said he thinks the point is probably from the Great Basin, it is made of a type of stone that could be from many places.

“What is interesting about it is the entire Pacific Rim has those kinds of rocks,” Stanford said. “It could have been from anywhere, like Japan. Or Mexico.

“In the old textbooks, people came from across the Bering Land Bridge, but we now know that boats have been invented more than 40,000 years ago. When you have boats, oceans and rivers are no longer barriers, they are highways.”

“He is here for a reason,” Stanford said, “and it is up to us to figure out what the reason is. From our point of view, it is up to us to tell his story.”

Like Owsley, Stanford said he is looking forward to publication of the book.

“It’s going to be the most-discussed skeleton in the world.”

Lynda V. Mapes: 206-464-2736 or lmapes@seattletimes.com

News where, when and how you want it

Email Icon

Hurry! Last two weeks to save 15%.

Hurry! Last two weeks to save 15%.

Reserve your copy of "The Seattle Sketcher," the long-awaited book by staff artist Gabriel Campanario, for the special price of just $29.95.

Advertising

Partner Video

Advertising


Advertising
The Seattle Times

The door is closed, but it's not locked.

Take a minute to subscribe and continue to enjoy The Seattle Times for as little as 99 cents a week.

Subscription options ►

Already a subscriber?

We've got good news for you. Unlimited seattletimes.com content access is included with most subscriptions.

Subscriber login ►