Carolyn Hax: He might be hurt, but he still doesn't get to dodge his wife's pregnancy
Advice columnist Carolyn Hax and her readers discuss whether a woman should tell her husband she's pregnant — because he's asked her not to.
DEAR CAROLYN: I had a miscarriage at 11 weeks last year, and my husband took it very hard. He told me he didn't want to know if I got pregnant again until the second trimester.
I have found out that I am expecting again, but now I am not sure whether I should tell him. I want to respect his feelings, but I also don't want him to regret not seeing those first milestones ... heartbeat, etc. There is also the selfish part of me who wants a hand to hold in case something goes wrong again.
— To Tell or Not to TellDEAR TELL: Way to "parent up," Dad.
The better time to talk to him about this, in depth, was before you got pregnant again. I realize how unhelpful this sounds, but I mention it because you might want to open your conversation with your husband by noting that you shouldn't have let his ignorance request go unchallenged.
It's not "the selfish part of you" that's telling you you're in this together. You are in this together, co-parents, a team in biological, emotional, financial and logistical senses. It's not right, fair or mature of him to delegate unilaterally a huge chunk of the emotional hard work to you.
While a miscarriage is a painful loss, it's not as if carrying a pregnancy into the second trimester will magically erase all possibility of any other pain. I mean, duh — as a parent, he's going to have to deal with all kinds of fear, pain and suspense. And since he'll have to suck it up at some point, he might as well start now.
You can have this whole conversation before telling him you're pregnant, but unless he's willing himself into cluelessness, he's probably going to guess. For what it's worth — while it will (rightly) feel false to withhold your news, opening with it introduces the risk that your husband will be too focused on the bean-spilling to listen carefully to the why. So, consider leading with the why and getting quickly to the what.
And if he fights you on the idea of emotional accountability and/or gets angry at you for telling, then it's time for a professional referee — marriage counseling or a marital workshop. You really, really don't want to go into parenthood with someone who thinks it's OK to use the emotional coping tactics of a 7-year-old.
RE: TELL OR NOT: Aren't there some very practical concerns regarding not telling her husband? What if they were in an accident or something, and medics had to know? And if she does miscarry, and has to go for an extraction, is she supposed to schedule that, drive herself there and back and deal with the emotional and physical ramifications of that alone because he's a delicate flower?
What a punk. Didn't he take "in sickness and in health" vows?
— AnonymousDEAR ANONYMOUS: No; he skipped them because they're upsetting.
An accident is a low-percentage possibility, but her wanting to express her emotions about a pregnancy — lost or successful — is about 100 percent. That he would prioritize his feelings and deny her the freedom to show hers is a problem they can't responsibly ignore.
Email Carolyn at email@example.com and