‘Legends of Oz: Dorothy’s Return’ is pretty charmless
A 1.5-star review of “Legends of Oz: Dorothy’s Return,” a harmless, almost charmless animated film that brings back Dorothy (voiced by Lea Michele) and her little dog, too.
McClatchy-Tribune News Service
‘Legends of Oz: Dorothy’s Return,’ with the voices of Lea Michele, Martin Short, Hugh Dancy, Oliver Platt, Bernadette Peters, Megan Hilty, Dan Aykroyd, Patrick Stewart, Jim Belushi. Directed by Will Finn and Dan St. Pierre, from a screenplay by Adam Balsam and Randi Barnes, based on a book by Roger S. Baum. 88 minutes. Rated PG for some scary images and mild peril. Several theaters.
“Legends of Oz: Dorothy’s Return” is a harmless but almost charmless adaptation of a book by L. Frank Baum’s grandson. It’s a derivative hash of grandpa’s story, set in the present day, given forgettable new tunes by pop songsmiths such as Bryan Adams that are sung by the likes of Lea Michele, Martin Short, Hugh Dancy and Megan Hilty.
And it’s in 3D, of course.
This work, animated at Prana in India, has decent production design — a dark, abandoned Emerald City; luscious-looking 3D sweets in Candy County. And the animated characters are beautifully rendered, even if their faces don’t have the expression and plasticity that Pixar, Blue Sky, Disney and Sony have managed in their recent films.
Dorothy (Michele), Toto, Auntie Em and Uncle Henry survive a tornado that trashes their corner of Kansas. An unscrupulous real-estate hustler (Martin Short) is ready to buy out the whole shattered town. But before Dorothy can stop this foreclosure fraud, a rainbow drags her back to Oz — her and her little dog, too.
Scarecrow (Dan Aykroyd) has smartly summoned her to save the land, which is under the thumb of The Jester (Short, again), the evil brother of the Wicked Witch of the West. And brother carries a grudge.
Dorothy — teaming up with Wiser, a chatterbox owl (Oliver Platt); a candy soldier, Marshal Mallow (Dancy); and the haughty China Princess (Hilty) — sets off down the ruined Yellow Brick Road to save her old friends.
The returning characters — the emotionally mercurial Tin Man (Kelsey Grammer), gutsy Lion (Jim Belushi) and trilling Glinda, the Good Witch (Bernadette Peters, perfectly cast) — have almost nothing to do. They’re just puppets of The Jester.
“No good can come from the reign of a fool,” Glinda trills, before Jester sics his flying monkeys on the legendary witch-killer from Kansas.
The singing is competent, but not one song will stick with you past the closing credits.
With unknown animation entities, the rule is that the more impressive the voice cast, the weaker the script. Hire great Brits Patrick Stewart, Brian Blessed and Dancy and maybe you can cover up the startling lack of humor on the page. Except it never does.