Originally published Wednesday, June 16, 2010 at 7:04 PM
Comments (0)
E-mail article
Print
Share
Comics: Graphic novel "Neil Young's Greendale" is satisfying
A tale of environmentalism
Scripps Howard News Service
It's weirdly appropriate that "Neil Young's Greendale" (DC/Vertigo, $19.99) has arrived as gallons of crude oil wash up on the white sand beaches of the Gulf coast.
Because one theme of "Greendale" is environmentalism. Another is natural synchronicity — of people, events and the huge wheel of fate. Whoa!
Anyway, "Greendale" is also a heartwarming coming-of-age story, a chilling contest with evil and a wondrous tale of "witchery." At least, that's what "Greendale" is in its graphic-novel form. I can't speak to what aspects are revealed of this strange little California town in its previous incarnations as 1) a concept album, 2) a rock opera and 3) an indie movie — none of which I have seen or heard.
And that turns out to be OK. In the hands of writer Joshua Dysart ("Unknown Soldier") and artist Cliff Chiang ("Green Arrow & Black Canary"), "Greendale" the graphic novel is completely satisfying as its own, singular animal.
It's the story of Sun Green — actually, of her entire family, but especially the Green women, most of whom disappear under odd circumstances, but all of whom have a connection to nature (abilities some townspeople describe as "witchery").
As 17-year-old Sun discovers her powers (and all the other wonders and distractions of being an attractive teenage girl), we also meet various members of her extended family — some of whom arrive only in dreams and hallucinations. We also meet The Stranger in Red, a character only the Green women can see, a "taker" (as described by Sun's great-grandmother) who is reminiscent, in a goose-pimply way, of The Walking Man in Stephen King's "The Stand."
Sun does some things we don't expect, but often her actions are as natural and comforting as a summer rain. My wife's reaction after reading "Greendale" was to re-experience that rain — to reminisce about her own younger years, when she, too, felt like a Green woman, "born with flames in our hands and bottled love in our hips."
But, oddly, I felt an empathy with Sun as well, despite being male. Perhaps that's the magic of adolescence, regardless of gender, or maybe just a tug from our roots — a reminder that we're all part of the natural world.
So I enjoyed "Greendale" immensely, just as scenes from the Gulf reminded me how prescient it is. Maybe that's synchronicity, maybe that's coincidence. Or maybe it's witchery.
"Neil Young's Greendale" is published on 100 percent recycled paper. More information is available at www.nygreendale.com.
Elsewhere:
Contact Andrew A. Smith of The (Memphis) Commercial Appeal at capncomics@aol.com or at http://captaincomics.ning.com
Movie review: 'The Adjustment Bureau': Hats off to a fine fantasy
Movie review: 'Beastly': Fairy-tale misfits who look like models
UPDATE - 08:57 AM
'Glee' could cover more Michael, Janet ... and ABBA
Movie review: 'Rango': Johnny Depp nails his role as the lizard hero in this wild Western
UPDATE - 09:14 AM
Carey 'embarrassed' over Gadhafi-linked concert
More Entertainment headlines...
![]()

Entertainment | Top Video | World | Offbeat Video | Sci-Tech
The engineers who create gallon-squeezing cars like the Toyota Prius use every available method to comply with the ever-tightening fuel-economy standa...
Post a comment
- Fasting woman to end attempt to ‘live on light’
- ‘I don’t want to be only person cured of HIV’
- Reporter who broke story on Gen. McChrystal dies in crash
- 2 charged with stealing 4.3 miles of copper wire from Sound Transit
- Man charged with tossing wife off cruise ship
- O’Bannon case could change NCAA landscape
- It’s curtains for Seattle’s Egyptian Theatre
- Most Americans hate their jobs or have 'checked out,' Gallup says
- Motel pool heater that killed 3 was replaced without permit
- Less than month after collapse, temporary I-5 bridge is finished
- Game thread: time for Mariners to surprise people
530 - Justin Smoak tries to save Mariners, reputation of young 'core'
95 - Justin Smoak appears headed up to rejoin reeling Mariners
94 - Taxi drivers stage a protest parade
91 - Woman trying to ‘live on light’ instead of food ends experiment
78 - Most hate their jobs or have ‘checked out,’ Gallup says
54 - A choice to be single in Seattle
51 - $231 million revenue jump could help break state budget stalemate
45 - Karzai: Afghan troops take lead to secure country
42 - ‘I don’t want to be only person cured of HIV’
41
- Most Americans hate their jobs or have 'checked out,' Gallup says
- It’s curtains for Seattle’s Egyptian Theatre
- ‘I don’t want to be only person cured of HIV’
- Fasting woman to end attempt to ‘live on light’
- One tough old bird rules the parking lot
- 2 charged with stealing 4.3 miles of copper wire from Sound Transit
- Foodie secrets of Florida’s ‘Redneck Riviera’ are worth the quest
- Mastros defend their actions, plan to ‘retire in peace’
- Ride-share cars: illegal, and all over Seattle
- Report: Too many teachers, too little quality







