Journalist argues religion is "man-made" and murderous in "God Is Not Great"
Christopher Hitchens is notorious for making mincemeat out of sacred cows, but in this book it is the sacred itself that is skewered.
The Washington Post
Christopher Hitchens discusses "God Is Not Great," 7:30 p.m. June 7, Town Hall, Seattle, co-sponsored by University Book Store and
"God Is Not Great: How Religion Poisons Everything"
by Christopher Hitchens
Twelve, 307 pp., $24.99
A century and a half ago, Pope Pius IX published the Syllabus of Errors, a rhetorical tour de force against the high crimes and misdemeanors of the modern world. "God Is Not Great," by British journalist and professional provocateur Christopher Hitchens, is the atheists' equivalent: an unrelenting enumeration of religion's sins and wickedness, written with much of the rhetorical pomp and all of the imperial condescension of a Vatican encyclical.
Hitchens, who once described Mother Teresa as "a fanatic, a fundamentalist, and a fraud," is notorious for making mincemeat out of sacred cows, but in this book it is the sacred itself that is skewered. Religion, Hitchens writes, is "violent, irrational, intolerant, allied to racism and tribalism and bigotry, invested in ignorance and hostile to free inquiry, contemptuous of women and coercive toward children." Channeling the anti-supernatural spirits of other acolytes of the "new atheism," Hitchens argues that religion is "man-made" and murderous, originating in fear and sustained by brute force. Like Richard Dawkins, he denounces the religious education of young people as child abuse. Like Sam Harris, he fires away at the Quran as well as the Bible. And like Daniel Dennett, he views faith as wish-fulfillment.
Christopher Hitchens discusses "God Is Not Great," 7:30 p.m. June 7, Town Hall, Seattle, co-sponsored by University Book Store and the Town Hall Center for Civic Life; $5 at the door (206-634-3400, www.ubookstore.com or www.townhallseattle.org).
Historian George Marsden once described fundamentalism as evangelicalism that is mad about something. If so, these evangelistic atheists have something in common with their fundamentalist foes, and Hitchens is the maddest of the lot. Protestant theologian John Calvin was "a sadist and torturer and killer," Hitchens writes, and the Bible "contain(s) a warrant for trafficking in humans, for ethnic cleansing, for slavery, for bride-price, and for indiscriminate massacre."
As should be obvious to any reasonable person — unlike Hitchens, I do not exclude believers from this category — horrors and good deeds are performed by believers and nonbelievers alike. But in Hitchens' Manichaean world, religion does little good and secularism hardly any evil. Indeed, Hitchens arrives at the conclusion that the secular murderousness of Stalin's purges wasn't really secular at all, since, as he quotes George Orwell, "a totalitarian state is in effect a theocracy." And in North Korea today, what has gone awry is not communism but Confucianism.
Hitchens is not so forgiving when it comes to religion's transgressions. He aims his poison pen at the Dalai Lama, St. Francis and Gandhi. Among religious leaders, only the Rev. Dr. Martin Luther King Jr. comes off well. But in the gospel according to Hitchens, whatever good King did accrues to his humanism rather than his Christianity.
Hitchens says a lot of true things in this wrongheaded book. He is right that you can be moral without being religious. He is right to track contemporary sexism and sexual repression to ancient religious beliefs. And his attack on "intelligent design" is not only convincing but comical. What Hitchens gets wrong is religion itself.
"God Is Not Great" assumes a childish definition of religion and then criticizes religious people for believing such foolery. But it is Hitchens who is the naif. To read this oddly innocent book as gospel is to believe that ordinary Catholics are proud of the Inquisition, that ordinary Hindus view masturbation as an offense against Krishna and that ordinary Jews cheer when a renegade Orthodox rebbe sucks the blood off a freshly circumcised penis.
If this is religion, then by all means we should have less of it. But the only people who believe that religion is about believing blindly in a God who blesses and curses on demand and sees science and reason as spawns of Satan are unlettered fundamentalists and their atheistic doppelgangers. Hitchens describes the religious mind as "literal and limited" and the atheistic mind as "ironic and inquiring." Readers with any sense of irony — and here I do not exclude believers — will be surprised to see how little inquiring Hitchens has done and how limited and literal is his own ill-prepared reduction of religion.
Christopher Hitchens is a brilliant man, and there is no living journalist I more enjoy reading. But I have never encountered a book whose author is so fundamentally unacquainted with its subject. In the end, this maddeningly dogmatic book does little more than illustrate one of Hitchens' pet themes: the ability of dogma to put reason to sleep.
Stephen Prothero is the chair of Boston University's religion department and the author of "Religious Literacy: What Every American Needs to Know — and Doesn't."
LeMay visitors can donate food to get a museum discount Throughout November, LeMay — America's Car Museum will offer a discount to those who don...
Post a comment